Skip to main content
VerdictTHE REDACTION · 2026-09-22

The Redaction

The record below is accurate. One statement had the attire entry struck out: pick the attire that makes that statement true again. Three wrong calls and the file closes.

The Vanishing Aboard the Aurelia — the Clay redaction

Days from the nearest port, the Aurelia is a locked room with an ocean for a moat. The brooch left its cabin; its owner did not. Chart the promenade deck, front to back. Statements were taken from all 5 passengers; Desmond Clay's is the first page.

The official record

cabinPassengerAttire (the redacted column)Deck activity
Cabin 1Desmond Clayemerald sashcard lounge
Cabin 2Ambrose Whitbybeaded shawlpurser's desk
Cabin 3Cordelia Ashewhite dinner jacketwireless office
Cabin 4Beatrice Lylevelvet cloakballroom
Cabin 5Theo Marchettifur stoleobservation deck

The redacted statement

6

Ambrose Whitby was in the cabin right before the passenger in the ______.

Which attire fills the blank?

The rest of the record stands. Use it to recover the struck line.

  • 1. Beatrice Lyle was right next to whoever spent the evening at the wireless office.
  • 2. Beatrice Lyle was in the cabin right before the passenger in the fur stole.
  • 3. The passenger in the emerald sash was in the cabin right before whoever spent the evening at the purser's desk.
  • 4. Desmond Clay and the passenger in the velvet cloak had exactly 2 cabins between them.
  • 5. The passenger in the emerald sash was in the cabin right before the passenger in the beaded shawl.
  • 7. The passenger in the white dinner jacket was in the cabin right before whoever spent the evening at the ballroom.
  • 8. Theo Marchetti and the passenger in the emerald sash had exactly 3 cabins between them.
  • 9. Desmond Clay and the passenger in the emerald sash are the same person.
  • 10. Theo Marchetti and whoever spent the evening at the purser's desk had exactly 2 cabins between them.
  • 11. The passenger in the emerald sash was in a lower-numbered cabin than whoever spent the evening at the wireless office.
  • 12. Cordelia Ashe was right next to whoever spent the evening at the ballroom.
  • 13. The passenger in the emerald sash was in a lower-numbered cabin than the passenger in the beaded shawl.
  • 14. Beatrice Lyle was right next to the passenger in the fur stole.
  • 15. The passenger in the emerald sash and whoever spent the evening at the card lounge are the same person.
  • 16. The passenger in the white dinner jacket and whoever spent the evening at the wireless office are the same person.

More free cases today

Download on the App StoreGet it on Google Play